When choosing between American Airlines and Alaska Airlines for your next trip, it’s essential to take a closer look at various factors, such as loyalty programs, cabin experiences, customer service, and route networks. Both carriers offer a unique set of benefits, making them appealing to different types of travelers.
In this article, we’ll dive deep into each airline’s strengths and weaknesses, covering everything from elite status to mileage plans, to help you make an informed decision.
Loyalty Programs: American AAdvantage vs. Alaska Airlines Mileage Plan
American AAdvantage Program
American Airlines runs the AAdvantage program, one of the most well-known frequent flyer programs in the world. Elite members of this program benefit from tiered statuses like Gold, Platinum, Platinum Pro, and Executive Platinum, which offer perks such as priority boarding, complimentary upgrades, and free checked bags. The program is also part of the oneworld alliance, granting members access to partner airlines, including British Airways and Hawaiian Airlines. This global reach makes it ideal for those who fly internationally or take long-haul flights regularly.
For frequent flyers, accumulating AAdvantage miles can open up a range of award travel options, from economy class to first class. American also allows you to earn miles through a variety of credit card partnerships, such as the Nerdwallet credit card. This adds flexibility to how you earn miles and redeem rewards, not just through air travel but also through daily financial decisions.
Alaska Airlines Mileage Plan
Alaska Airlines operates the Mileage Plan, which is also highly regarded among frequent flyers. Although Alaska Airlines doesn’t have the same global presence as American Airlines, it has carved out a niche, especially for travelers on the West Coast and those flying to and from hubs like San Francisco. What makes the Alaska Airlines Mileage Plan standout is its generous mileage earning structure. Unlike most airlines that offer miles based on the price of the ticket, Alaska Airlines allows you to earn miles based on the distance flown, which can be more beneficial for long-haul flights.
In addition, Alaska Airlines passengers enjoy the benefit of its partnership with over a dozen airlines, including oneworld alliance members, allowing them to earn and redeem Alaska miles on partner flights. Elite members of the Mileage Plan enjoy perks similar to American’s AAdvantage program, with Alaska MVP Gold and higher levels offering priority check-in, same-day flight changes, and complimentary upgrades on eligible flights.
Cabin Experience: Main Cabin vs. Premium Economy vs. First Class
American Airlines Cabin Options
American Airlines offers a wide variety of cabin choices, from basic economy fares to luxurious first-class options. The main cabin experience is standard but includes the essentials for a comfortable flight. However, opting for premium economy seat selection on American will offer more legroom, priority boarding, and additional amenities. Those flying in first class will enjoy a more elevated experience, with better seat comfort, gourmet dining options, and priority check-in.
For business travelers, booking a business class ticket is also an attractive option on American Airlines, especially for international routes where lie-flat seats and access to exclusive lounges add significant value. Executive Platinum members benefit from lounge access even when flying domestically, which enhances the overall travel experience.
Alaska Airlines Cabin Options
Alaska Airlines offers a streamlined but highly satisfying range of cabin experiences. The main cabin provides comfort with friendly service, while their premium economy seats, called Premium Class, offer more legroom and early boarding for a reasonable upgrade fee. However, Alaska Airlines shines in its first-class offering, which is regarded as one of the best in the domestic airline industry. First-class passengers enjoy spacious seats, gourmet meals, and access to the Alaska Lounge, making it a popular choice for travelers who want a more personalized experience.
Customer Service: Which Airline Delivers Better?
American Airlines Customer Service
American Airlines has made strides in improving customer service, but it has historically faced criticism for long wait times and inconsistent service. That said, elite members often report a better experience, as they are given priority access to phone lines and special services. In recent years, American has invested in its mobile app and digital experiences, providing tools that make managing your flights more convenient, such as mobile check-in, flight tracking, and same-day flight change requests.
However, some travelers still find that navigating the airline’s complex fees—such as those for baggage and transaction fees for changes—can be frustrating. That said, American offers the advantage of a larger route network, meaning you can fly just about anywhere in the world on American or its partners.
Alaska Airlines Customer Service
Alaska Airlines has earned a stellar reputation for customer service, often scoring higher than many of its competitors, including American Airlines. Alaska’s employees are known for their friendly demeanor and willingness to assist passengers. Its loyalty to a strong customer experience is a reason why it consistently receives high marks in traveler satisfaction surveys.
The Alaska Airlines mobile app is user-friendly and offers a smooth experience for booking flights, checking in, and managing itineraries. Additionally, elite members receive priority boarding and priority check-in, further enhancing their travel experience.
Route Networks: American Airlines vs. Alaska Airlines
American Airlines Route Network
As the largest airline in the United States, American Airlines has an expansive route network that spans not only the U.S. but also the globe. Whether you’re flying within the U.S., to the Caribbean, Europe, or Asia, American Airlines likely has a flight that suits your needs. Its partnership with British Airways and other members of the oneworld alliance gives travelers even more options for international travel.
Alaska Airlines Route Network
While Alaska Airlines doesn’t have the same global reach as American, it is unmatched when it comes to routes on the West Coast and flights to Hawaii. It serves key cities like San Francisco and Seattle with frequent Alaska flights. Its partnerships with other airlines like Hawaiian Airlines and its membership in the oneworld alliance broaden its reach, making it easier to book international flights using Alaska miles.
Fees and Hidden Costs: A Comparison
American Airlines Fees
When flying with American, travelers should be aware of various fees that may arise, such as baggage fees, services fees, and regulatory fees on award tickets. There are also transaction fees for changing tickets unless you have elite status or booked a more flexible fare class. Be sure to read the advertiser disclosure when signing up for American-branded credit cards to avoid unexpected fees.
Alaska Airlines Fees
Alaska Airlines tends to be more straightforward with its fees, and many travelers appreciate the simplicity of its fare structures. That said, you should still be mindful of possible fees related to seat selection, baggage, and same-day change options.
Other Financial Considerations
For those looking to make the most out of their airline credit cards or investing their loyalty points into broader financial products, both airlines have partnerships with various financial institutions. American Airlines, for instance, works with Nerdwallet credit card for AAdvantage members to accumulate more points.
Alaska Airlines’ parent company has partnered with financial services companies such as Atomic Invest to provide financial products and investment options through Atomic brokerage llc and Atomic treasury account. If you’re a frequent flyer, you might also benefit from services offered by Atomic invest to better manage your earnings from miles and points, ensuring that they contribute positively to your financial planning. Keep in mind the advertiser disclosure when reviewing these offers.
Final Thoughts: Which Airline is Best for You?
Both American Airlines and Alaska Airlines have their strengths, and the best choice largely depends on your travel needs. If you fly internationally and want access to a vast network of partner airlines, American Airlines might be the better option, especially with its membership in the oneworld alliance. Additionally, its AAdvantage program offers extensive opportunities to earn miles and enjoy elite perks.
On the other hand, if you primarily fly domestically, particularly on the West Coast, Alaska Airlines is hard to beat. Its Mileage Plan is consistently ranked as one of the best, and the airline’s focus on customer service makes it a favorite among frequent flyers.
Consider your flight patterns, the benefits of each airline’s loyalty program, and the level of service you prefer when deciding between the two. Regardless of which airline you choose, both offer excellent ways to make the most out of your travel and loyalty points.
Comments